Do I demand an editor credit?

Get new comments by email
You can cancel email alerts at anytime.
Comments (3)

dollerbill in Las Vegas, Nevada

50 months ago

Through a mutual acquaintance I became attached to a feature film right before post production began. At first I was told I would come on board as an assistant editor, logging footage and syncing the film with the audio. Shortly after I had finish those tasks, I started cutting the footage. It started out as cutting small scenes but quickly grew into hours spent alone cutting 20 scene sequences at a time, and having the director sit with me as we went over my cut. The rough cut is days away from being completed and I have done most of the actual editing of the film. The last I heard I was still only going to get an assistant credit, but I feel that that will be an insult to the time and energy I have put into this project and will not accurately reflect the work I did, especially when I list it on my resume or future applications. Should I tell the director my thoughts and let him know I feel I deserve the credit, or should I be happy with the assistant position?

Thanks

- Was this comment helpful? Yes / No Reply - Report abuse

Chris Northcross in Pontiac, Michigan

43 months ago

How closely does the final film resemble your rough cut?

- Was this comment helpful? Yes / No Reply - Report abuse

Allen Ferro in North Hollywood, California

41 months ago

I'm a member of MPEG local 700, motion picture editors guild since 1979

The issues are the following: Is there another editor on the job working with you? If so, then you might be relegated to the 1st assistant credit. I must assume that this is not a union feature because they would be in violation of many provisions, so let's go forward from there.

I'll tell you that people are generally warped when it comes to the creative process. From what you are telling us about your involvement with the film, you are functioning as the editor. Not my opinion, just fact based on the description that the MPAA uses to describe what an editor is. This has nothing to do with experience, or any subjective matter. You're working with the director, cutting scenes and building a feature cut. That makes you an editor.

My take is that you deserve the credit only if there is no other contributing editor that has been contracted to edit the feature. No one is going to have the balls to confront the issue past that, as this is common practice to exploit talented individuals at little or no money to get the job done. So, if you do a good job, and lots of people (including yourself), like the end product, and they finish it that way, You should get the credit.

Now one last think. This is how assistant editors get editing jobs. They put together a reel that shows the work that they did. Who else will be more intimate with your cut than you are? I'm a seasoned pro and I couldn't b.s. my way through lying about what take you used for any given scene, but you can. So, if all else fails, you have materials to build your reel so that you can search for work in the future.

Best of luck,

Allen Ferro

- Was this comment helpful? Yes / No Reply - Report abuse

» Sign in or create an account to comment on this topic.