13 Tips for Interviewing Candidates

Updated August 10, 2023

GettyImages-890837584 optimized
Image description

A person asks the person opposite them a question while holding a document in their hand.

Prior to hiring new employees for your company, you'll want to conduct a round of interviews to ensure you make the right new-hire selection. The more comfortable you make a candidate during their interview, the greater chance you'll have of gaining valuable insight into who they are.

In this article, we list the benefits of the interview process, provide 13 tips for interviewing candidates and answer frequently asked questions on how to interview someone for a job.

Related jobs on Indeed
Part-time jobs
View more jobs on Indeed

What are the benefits of interviewing candidates?

Here are some of the benefits that come from interviewing a job candidate:

Learn valuable information about your candidate

Interviewing a job candidate gives you an opportunity to learn more about your prospective employee, which can help you determine whether they're qualified for the position. For example, you can learn about their qualifications and whether their personality matches your company culture and their prospective team.

Prevent bias

In the event you favor a candidate for a certain personality trait or skill, holding an interview with consistent review metrics helps you look at each candidate more objectively. While your bias may not be intentional, conducting candidate interviews offers you a greater perspective and can ensure you hire without any favoritism.

Related: How To Evaluate Interview Candidates (With Steps and Tips)

Test your candidate's skills

During an interview, you have the opportunity to see how candidates perform under stressful situations. Providing them with a test relevant to their industry or the job they're interviewing for will give them the chance to showcase their skills and qualifications.

It also allows you to assess how well they work under pressure and helps you determine whether their qualifications align with the position you're hiring for.

Determine the candidate's fit with the company culture

Holding a panel interview, in particular, allows you to assess their fit with the company's culture. A panel interview allows candidates to interact with their prospective colleagues and lets you determine how well they get along with each one.

Related: Guide To In-Person Interviews

How to interview a candidate

Use these 13 tips to help you interview a candidate effectively:

1. Be prepared

Take time to prepare for each interview to help both you and the candidate get the most out of it. Here are some ways to prepare for an interview:

  • Prepare a list of qualifications and duties for the job. If needed, consult with the manager or supervisor for the role to get a better idea of what they're looking for in a new hire.

  • Make a list of questions you want to ask. Make sure the questions you ask get job candidates to elaborate on their qualifications and allow you to gain insight regarding their potential fit with your company's culture.

  • Review the resume. Take note of anything you'd like them to elaborate on during the interview. You can also look up their social media accounts to get an idea of who they are.

  • Consider what they may ask you. Be ready to answer any questions the candidate might have regarding the open position, employee benefits and the company at large.

  • Understand your company's goals and culture. To give your company a solid pitch, get to know your company's goals and its culture so you know what to say to each candidate.

Related: 125 Common Interview Questions and Answers (With Tips)

2. Take notes

During the interview, take notes of each candidate's answers. If you're interviewing several candidates, taking notes can help you remember each interview you conducted. You can even type up your notes after the interview. The notes you take can serve as a reference when you start to compare candidates and make a hiring decision.

3. Ask for specific details

Since candidates have the potential to exaggerate their contributions to their previous employers, seek the truth by asking specific questions. For example, consider asking how many people they supervised with their management position or their sales numbers from last year.

Get as many numbers or dates as you can and bring them up again later in the interview to help you determine their validity. If they lied about the details they provided you, they're more likely to forget the information they gave you earlier in the interview.

Related: 69 Good Interview Questions To Ask Candidates

4. Discuss salary

To ensure you're in agreement with candidates regarding the job's salary, ask them what their salary expectations are. If they're hoping for more than what you're offering, they may look for opportunities elsewhere.

Related: 12 Questions To Ask During Job Offer Negotiation

5. Ask about their short-term roles

During the interview, ask about any previous roles they had that lasted less than two years. If a candidate has multiple short-term roles, it may indicate some problems.

Ask them why they left these roles. If they talk about problems they had that will be the same with the position they're interviewing for, they may not be the best fit for the job.

For example, if they didn't like working early in the morning and you're only offering an early morning shift, they may not want to continue pursuing the position.

6. Show you care

Provide your candidates with a good experience by showing that you care. Doing so can help them feel more comfortable while also helping your company's reputation.

Even if they don't get the job, showing you care and treating them well can still make them feel good about your company and may encourage them to apply for another position in the future.

Make sure to make them feel welcome, focus on the conversation, take your time and give them the opportunity to ask you questions at the end of the interview.

Related: How To Write a Thank You for Applying Letter

7. Provide structure to the interview

Instead of having a free-flowing conversation, provide some structure to the interview. Having structure can help you stay focused and ensures you address everything you wanted to during the interview.

For example, start with a brief description of the company and the job, then explain the job duties and end with the candidate's questions. The latter gives them the opportunity to ask questions about the position and the company.

Read more: How To Create an Effective Interview Structure

8. Extend professional courtesies

At the start of the interview, make small talk with the candidate to help them feel comfortable. For example, ask them how their day has been or if they had difficulty finding the building.

You can also offer them a glass of water. If you have time, arrive at the interview early and offer to give them a tour of the office.

9. Ask the same questions

When you interview for a particular position, ask each candidate the same questions. This consistency makes it easier to compare candidates as you prepare to make a hiring decision.

10. Learn about their career goals

Apart from asking role-specific questions, aim to get a better understanding of the interviewee's career goals. Ask them about their professional interests, where they see themselves in 10 years and why they're particularly interested in the position they're interviewing for.

Asking these questions helps you understand what they expect regarding professional development. In addition, they give you an idea of how they perceive your company and the position.

11. Allow them to ask questions

Toward the end of the interview, give the candidate time to ask you any questions they have about the position and your company. This helps them evaluate whether or not they see the position as a good fit for them. It also helps you determine their level of interest in the position and their overall understanding of the company.

Read more: Interview Question: "Do You Have Any Questions for Me?"

12. Talk about the next steps

At the end of the interview, explain the next steps in the interview process and what they can expect. Let them know when they can expect to a response from you and what the rest of the interview process may look like. You can also let them know your timeline for filling the position.

13. Be a good listener

Throughout the interview, make sure to actively listen and stay engaged. Being a good listener shows your genuine interest in the candidate, as well as gives them the encouragement they need to talk more openly about their qualifications for the role they're interviewing for.

In addition to listening, learn to understand nonverbal cues, which can indicate their level of interest in the position as well as their honesty.

Related: Passive vs. Active Listening: What's the Difference?

Do you need help with your resume?

FAQ about interviewing candidates

Here are some frequently asked questions about interviewing job candidates:

What are ways to make the candidate comfortable?

Be kind and friendly to every candidate you interview. Greet them with a smile, arrive on time and make sure to hold the interview in a comfortable location.

What is the STAR method for interviewing candidates?

This refers to a technique that allows candidates to highlight their qualifications by answering interview questions using the STAR method as follows: Situation, Task, Action and Result.

Related: How To Successfully Start an Interview (Plus Tips)

What are some common interview questions?

While you should ask candidates questions relevant to the position you're hiring for, you can also ask some general questions to get an overview of who they are. Here are some common interview questions:

  • Can you tell me about yourself?

  • What are your strengths and weaknesses?

  • Why do you want to work for us?

  • Why are you leaving your current job?

  • Can you tell me about a time you overcame a challenge?

Apart from these common questions, ask other questions such as behavioral questions, situational questions and emotional intelligence questions to help you determine whether they're a good fit for the role.

Is this article helpful?
Explore your next job opportunity on IndeedFind jobs

Related Articles

How to Succeed at Your Second Interview (With 8 Tips)

Explore more articles

  • FAQ: What Does It Mean To Be Shortlisted for a Job?
  • What Is a Market Research Analyst? (With Duties and Skills)
  • 12 Master's in Industrial-Organizational Psychology Jobs
  • 10 Tips on How to Apply for a Job Online
  • 56 Jobs To Pursue With a Bachelor's Degree in Social Science
  • 26 High-Paying Jobs in Pediatrics (Plus Salaries)
  • Degree in Community Health: Types, Career Paths and Skills
  • How To Become a Bouncer in 8 Steps (With Salary and Duties)
  • Is It Better To Apply for Jobs in Person or Online?
  • Highest-Paying Jobs: 12 You Can Pursue Without a Degree
  • How To Reply to a Job Application Acknowledgment: 8 Steps
  • Job vs. Internship: Which Should You Choose?