High-paying insurance jobs in Indianapolis
Insurance assesses risk and provides coverage for individuals and businesses. Agents sell policies and help clients navigate claims. Strong analytical and customer service skills are essential.
We found 98 high-paying for you in Indianapolis, IN. These insurance jobs pay well, with salaries between $44,123 to $101,167 per hour. Popular roles include Insurance Agent, Insurance Producer and Claims Representative.
Job title
Updated Oct 16, 2026Actuary
Indianapolis
Indiana
Underwriter
Indianapolis
Indiana
Insurance Agent
Indianapolis
Indiana
Insurance Producer
Indianapolis
Indiana
Adjuster
Indianapolis
Indiana
Claims Specialist
Indianapolis
Indiana
Claims Representative
Indianapolis
Indiana
Job descriptions below are for educational purposes. Please refer to the employer's job description for complete details.
-
Actuary
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Actuaries help develop insurance policies and pricing strategies using statistical methods to predict future events and analyze financial risks. Proficiency in mathematics, analytical thinking and expertise in statistical analysis are essential in this role.
The top companies hiring Actuary in Indianapolis, IN are Deloitte (4 jobs), Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance (2 jobs), and Ascensus (1 job).
Actuary jobs take 8 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 55% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 20% of job openings are part-time roles.
See 6 jobsAverage pay
Indianapolis
$101,167 per yearIndiana
$100,603 per yearSkills
- Communication skills
- SQL
- Analysis skills
- Pricing
- Python
-
Underwriter
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Underwriters assess insurance applications, ensure compliance for policy issuance and analyze information to inform decisions and manage risk. Strong analytical skills, attention to detail and knowledge of underwriting policies are key in this role.
The top companies hiring Underwriter in Indianapolis, IN are The Hanover Insurance Group (2 jobs), Huntington Bank (1 job), and Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance (1 job).
Underwriter jobs take 43 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 49% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 10% of job openings are part-time roles.
See 4 jobsAverage pay
Indianapolis
$88,740 per yearIndiana
$85,139 per yearSkills
- Microsoft Office
- IT
- Microsoft Excel
- Analysis skills
-
Insurance Agent
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Insurance Agents sell policies, assess client needs, and provide customer support. Sales skills, product knowledge, and excellent communication abilities are essential.
The top companies hiring Insurance Agent in Indianapolis, IN are State Farm (7 jobs), Farmers Insurance Group (4 jobs), and American Family Insurance (4 jobs).
Insurance Agent jobs take 128 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 22% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 6% of job openings are part-time roles.
See 58 jobsAverage pay
Indianapolis
$70,796 per yearIndiana
$72,969 per yearSkills
- Communication skills
- Sales
- Negotiation
- Business development
-
Insurance Producer
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Insurance producers generate and manage insurance business by developing client relationships, assessing needs and presenting appropriate products. Strong sales skills, a focus on customer service and industry knowledge are essential for this role.
Insurance Producer jobs take 163 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 27% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 4% of job openings are part-time roles.
See 11 jobsAverage pay
Indianapolis
$65,051 per yearIndiana
$55,021 per yearSkills
- Sales
- Communication skills
- Insurance sales
- Customer service
- Negotiation
-
Adjuster
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Adjusters assess insurance claims, investigate damage, determine payouts, analyze information and negotiate settlements. Attention to detail, strong analytical skills and effective communication are essential in this role.
The top companies hiring Adjuster in Indianapolis, IN are INTEGRA TESTING SERVICES (3 jobs), Indianapolis Public Schools (2 jobs), and My Claim Warrior (1 job).
Adjuster jobs take 36 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 46% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 6% of job openings are part-time roles.
See 6 jobsAverage pay
Indianapolis
$30.24 per hourIndiana
$28.41 per hourSkills
- Customer service
- Organizational skills
- Negotiation
- Analysis skills
- Communication skills
-
Claims Specialist
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Claims specialists manage claims processes, evaluate documentation and communicate with clients, ensuring accuracy and compliance. Attention to detail, analytical thinking and strong organizational skills are essential in this role.
The top companies hiring Claims Specialist in Indianapolis, IN are Liberty Mutual Insurance (2 jobs), First Chicago Insurance Company (1 job), and Core specialty (1 job).
Claims Specialist jobs take 33 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 36% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 1% of job openings are part-time roles.
See 6 jobsAverage pay
Indianapolis
$19.66 per hourIndiana
$19.97 per hourSkills
- Communication skills
- Microsoft Office
- Organizational skills
- Analysis skills
- Customer service
-
Claims Representative
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Claims representatives manage claims inquiries, communicate with all parties involved and ensure timely responses, supporting clients through the process. Strong communication skills, attention to detail and problem-solving abilities are essential in this role.
Claims Representative jobs take 33 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 28% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 3% of job openings are part-time roles.
See 7 jobsAverage pay
Indianapolis
$18.90 per hourIndiana
$17.87 per hour