Average salary
$20.06
- Select pay period
- per hourMost common pay period for Server at this company
- per dayConverted from most common pay period
- per weekConverted from most common pay period
- per monthConverted from most common pay period
- per yearConverted from most common pay period
18%
Above national average
Average $20.06
Low $7.25
High $47.85
Salary estimated from 33 past and present job postings on Indeed. Last updated: May 4, 2026
Compare all Server salaries in the United States
More First Watch Food Preparation & Service salaries
Restaurant Manager
$52.77 per hour
4 salaries reported
All First Watch - Food Preparation & Service salaries
Reviews about Pay and benefits for Server in First Watch
January 25, 2024
Fun
Server
Columbus, OH
It’s a chill place to work. Good people and tips, but a bit over staffed on weekends. A great way to dip your toe into serving if you don’t have other experience.
October 4, 2019
First watch
Server
Reynoldsburg, OH
This job was a fun environment. It was definitely meant to be a first time job out of high school where I would build relationships with customers. It really got stressful on the weekends or on special holidays...Show more
May 26, 2026
Good money but too much work
Server
Louisville, KY
You will end up making good money but the amount of work you do is not comparable, managers are not very helpful and will be very hypocritical. Good pay but you will work for it.
See all First Watch Server reviews about Pay and benefits
Common questions about salaries at First Watch
Browse all First Watch salaries by category
How much does a Server make at First Watch in the United States?
Average First Watch Server hourly pay in the United States is approximately $20.06, which is 18% above the national average.
Salary estimated from 1,183 past and present job postings on Indeed.
Please note that all salary figures are approximations based upon third party submissions to Indeed. These figures are given to the Indeed users for the purpose of generalized comparison only. Minimum wage may differ by jurisdiction and you should consult the employer for actual salary figures.