High-paying insurance jobs in Madison
Insurance assesses risk and provides coverage for individuals and businesses. Agents sell policies and help clients navigate claims. Strong analytical and customer service skills are essential.
We found 69 high-paying for you in Madison, WI. These insurance jobs pay well, with salaries between $43,901 to $113,618 per hour. Popular roles include Insurance Agent, Claims Representative and Actuary.
Job title
Updated Nov 10, 2026Actuary
Madison
Wisconsin
Compliance Consultant
Madison
Wisconsin
Claims Specialist
Madison
Wisconsin
Senior Underwriter
Madison
Wisconsin
Underwriter
Madison
Wisconsin
Claims Supervisor
Madison
Wisconsin
Insurance Agent
Madison
Wisconsin
Claims Adjuster
Madison
Wisconsin
Claims Representative
Madison
Wisconsin
Insurance Producer
Madison
Wisconsin
Job descriptions below are for educational purposes. Please refer to the employer's job description for complete details.
-
Actuary
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Actuaries help develop insurance policies and pricing strategies using statistical methods to predict future events and analyze financial risks. Proficiency in mathematics, analytical thinking and expertise in statistical analysis are essential in this role.
The top companies hiring Actuary in Madison, WI are Medica Services Company LLC (3 jobs), TruStage (1 job), and American Family Insurance (1 job).
Actuary jobs take 9 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 49% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 4% of job openings are part-time roles.
See jobsAverage pay
Madison
$113,618 per yearWisconsin
$138,987 per year -
Compliance Consultant
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Compliance Consultants ensure organizations adhere to legal standards and regulations, assess policies and provide strategic recommendations. Strong analytical skills, knowledge of regulations, and business acumen are essential for success.
Currently, 25% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 4% of job openings are part-time roles.
See jobsAverage pay
Madison
$111,920 per yearWisconsin
$105,729 per year -
Claims Specialist
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Claims specialists manage claims processes, evaluate documentation and communicate with clients, ensuring accuracy and compliance. Attention to detail, analytical thinking and strong organizational skills are essential in this role.
Claims Specialist jobs take 27 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 39% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 2% of job openings are part-time roles.
See jobsAverage pay
Madison
$105,893 per yearWisconsin
$84,042 per year -
Senior Underwriter
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Senior underwriters assess complex insurance applications, manage underwriting guidelines, make underwriting decisions, mentor junior staff and enhance processes. Analytical skills, leadership abilities and strong industry knowledge are essential in this role
Senior Underwriter jobs take 78 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 38% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 0% of job openings are part-time roles.
See jobsAverage pay
Madison
$88,179 per yearWisconsin
$106,992 per year -
Underwriter
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Underwriters assess insurance applications, ensure compliance for policy issuance and analyze information to inform decisions and manage risk. Strong analytical skills, attention to detail and knowledge of underwriting policies are key in this role.
Underwriter jobs take 40 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 46% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 4% of job openings are part-time roles.
See jobsAverage pay
Madison
$80,302 per yearWisconsin
$82,824 per yearSkills
- Microsoft Office
- IT
- Microsoft Excel
- Analysis skills
-
Claims Supervisor
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Claims Supervisors oversee claims processing teams, mentor staff and resolve complex issues to ensure compliance and effective operations. Leadership, strong organizational skills and industry knowledge are crucial.
Claims Supervisor jobs take 1 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 75% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 0% of job openings are part-time roles.
See jobsAverage pay
Madison
$77,272 per yearWisconsin
$96,945 per year -
Insurance Agent
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Insurance Agents sell policies, assess client needs, and provide customer support. Sales skills, product knowledge, and excellent communication abilities are essential.
The top companies hiring Insurance Agent in Madison, WI are American Family Insurance (9 jobs), Allstate Insurance (2 jobs), and Farmers Insurance Group (2 jobs).
Insurance Agent jobs take 130 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 23% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 6% of job openings are part-time roles.
See jobsAverage pay
Madison
$76,989 per yearWisconsin
$70,929 per yearSkills
- Communication skills
- Sales
- Negotiation
- Business development
-
Claims Adjuster
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Claims adjusters evaluate insurance claims, investigate circumstances, determine settlements and communicate with all parties involved. Strong analytical skills, negotiation abilities and attention to detail are essential for success.
The top companies hiring Claims Adjuster in Madison, WI are Progressive (1 job), Rural Mutual Insurance Company (1 job), and SustainableHR (1 job).
Claims Adjuster jobs take 40 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 46% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 10% of job openings are part-time roles.
See jobsAverage pay
Madison
$71,696 per yearWisconsin
$69,618 per year -
Claims Representative
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Claims representatives manage claims inquiries, communicate with all parties involved and ensure timely responses, supporting clients through the process. Strong communication skills, attention to detail and problem-solving abilities are essential in this role.
The top companies hiring Claims Representative in Madison, WI are Auto-Owners Insurance (2 jobs), RAS Companies (2 jobs), and Zurich Insurance (1 job).
Claims Representative jobs take 43 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 25% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 3% of job openings are part-time roles.
See jobsAverage pay
Madison
$65,343 per yearWisconsin
$62,902 per year -
Insurance Producer
Review job description
Please refer to the employers job description for complete details.
Insurance producers generate and manage insurance business by developing client relationships, assessing needs and presenting appropriate products. Strong sales skills, a focus on customer service and industry knowledge are essential for this role.
The top companies hiring Insurance Producer in Madison, WI are Farmers Insurance Group (1 job), Horace Mann Insurance (1 job), and TRICOR Insurance (1 job).
Insurance Producer jobs take 134 days on average from job posting to starting date. Currently, 25% of job openings offer remote or hybrid positions and 5% of job openings are part-time roles.
See jobsAverage pay
Madison
$43,901 per yearWisconsin
$91,589 per year