1. Long or unclear hiring timelines
Many candidates apply for multiple jobs at the same time. If your hiring team takes too long to send out updates or schedule interviews, candidates may accept a job with another company. An extended interview process can also cause you to lose quality candidates, especially if you operate in a competitive labor market.
Before you can create a faster timeline, determine why the hiring process is taking so much time. For example, you might be experiencing delays if your hiring managers have to wait for leadership approval before scheduling interviews or sending offers.
Here are some ways to fix long hiring timelines:
- Inform candidates of the upcoming hiring stages and estimated timeline.
- Send automated messages between interviews to help keep candidates engaged in the process.
- Use fewer rounds of interviews to make the hiring process more efficient.
- Communicate about delays quickly to show candidates that you value their time.
- Streamline your internal approval processes for each stage of hiring.
A faster hiring process can improve the candidate experience and retain high-quality candidates. It can also reduce your cost per hire and help you fill positions in less time.
2. Stopping communication without warning
One of the most common bad hiring practices happens when you suddenly stop communicating with applicants. This practice, which is also called ghosting, can leave candidates feeling confused and uncertain.
For example, a candidate may have a positive first interview but receive no update regarding the next steps. They might assume that you’ve hired someone or that you’re no longer interested in them.
Here’s how to avoid ghosting candidates:
- Follow up after a job interview to let applicants know when they can expect an update from you next.
- Explain what your interview process involves, especially if you’re planning multiple rounds of interviews.
- Streamline your hiring process to address efficiency issues.
- Tell candidates if they’re not selected for the job as soon as you fill the position.
- Encourage candidates to contact you if they have questions.
Providing transparent and timely updates can help you build trust with candidates. Even if they don’t get the job, they may be willing to apply again in the future.
3. Requiring unpaid or lengthy screening assignments
Screening tests and sample assignments are standard practice in many industries, but it’s important to use them thoughtfully. If these assignments take a great deal of time, you could risk losing high-quality candidates. And because these tasks are unpaid, candidates may perceive them as unfair hiring practices. This perspective can affect your reputation as an employer.
If your open role requires an assignment or test during the interview process, make sure the task is directly related to the role. Consider compensating candidates for any task that takes longer than 15-30 minutes.
Here are a few ways to avoid requiring long or unpaid assignments:
- Assign quick trial projects that take less than 30 minutes to complete.
- Consider a paid test if you need a bigger sample of a candidate’s work.
- Use structured questions or skills-based interviews instead of test projects.
- Give clear instructions in advance and explain how long the task might take.
- Request work samples or a job portfolio instead of a test assignment.
Showing candidates that you respect their time can help you stand out from other employers.
4. Confusing or complicated applications
If your application form is overly long or confusing, candidates may abandon it before submitting. Fortunately, this is a relatively easy issue to resolve.
Here’s how to fix confusing or complicated applications:
- Include only necessary questions.
- Avoid questions that don’t help you learn about a candidate’s skills.
- Ask candidates to apply using a single online form.
Allow candidates to save their applications to finish later. Eliminate questions that aren’t directly related to the job.
A straightforward application process can make it easier for candidates to complete every field. It can also improve their perception of your business. An organized and concise application may suggest that you have an efficient hiring process and a clearly defined position.
5. Pausing or canceling the role without notice
Sometimes, your company may need to pause or cancel a job opening. This can happen due to budget changes or shifting priorities. If you don’t inform candidates about the change, they may perceive it as a bad hiring practice.
Here are some ways to avoid pausing or canceling roles without notice:
- Let candidates know as soon as you end the hiring process for the open job.
- Provide a simple explanation to reduce uncertainty and reassure candidates that they’re not to blame.
- Ask candidates if you can store their application and contact information to consider for future jobs.
- Provide a new timeline if you plan to reopen the hiring process later.
By updating candidates, you demonstrate that you value their time. It can be an effective way to maintain a positive employer brand.
6. Unclear or inaccurate job descriptions
Candidates often decide whether to apply based on the details in your job listing. To help them make an informed decision, write a job description that’s comprehensive and accurate.
Ways to create effective job descriptions include:
- Ensure the text reflects the current duties and responsibilities of the role.
- Include information about daily activities.
- Highlight skills and transferable skills to support a skills-first hiring process and attract a wider range of candidates.
- Provide a salary range and list the benefits your company provides.
- Describe the work environment and collaboration style.
Avoiding bad hiring practices shows candidates you value their time and effort. By making an effort to build a considerate, organized process, you can hire high-quality candidates faster and improve your reputation as an employer.