What is employee self-feedback?

Employee self-feedback, also known as an employee self-evaluation, enables employees to document their strengths and weaknesses at work. They can also provide examples of how they’ve demonstrated their abilities or completed tasks beyond their scope or their role’s general responsibilities. You can use a standard form to help them assess different skills and performance metrics. Employees might conduct a self-evaluation once a year, typically before a performance review. You might include these questions on your self-evaluation: What process did you improve last year? Is there a specific project outcome you’re proud of? How do you demonstrate leadership skills with colleagues? What resources would help you increase productivity? What parts of your job deliver the most job satisfaction? How would you like to grow in this role or eventually transition to a new position? Are there any goals you didn’t meet? What goals do you have for the next quarter, and how do you plan to achieve them? What’s a company value you resonate with and demonstrate in your work?

Giving Feedback to Employees: A Manager's Guide

Our mission

Indeed’s Employer Guide helps businesses grow and manage their workforce. With over 15,000 articles in 6 languages, we offer tactical advice, how-tos and best practices to help businesses hire and retain great employees.

Read our editorial guidelines

6 min read

Constructive feedback helps support employee growth and development. By communicating what your team members are doing well and where they can improve, workers can refine their skills and potentially establish opportunities for lateral growth or promotions. Consistent feedback can also positively affect your company culture, workplace relationships and company productivity.

In this article, find out how to give effective feedback, explore best practices and read examples of constructive critiques.

Start your job posting, instantly

Create job description

Start your job posting, instantly

Create job description

What is employee feedback?

Employee feedback involves providing assessments, suggestions or comments about employees’ performance and skills. You might deliver positive or constructive feedback in person or in writing. You could provide quick, informal feedback in conversation or evaluate the employee during a formal performance review.

Feedback helps employees understand whether their performance meets expectations. It also provides an external perspective on their strengths and opportunities for improvement.

Managers can shape employee behavior by providing two types of feedback:

Constructive feedback: Helps employees understand what they can improve. You might address behavior, underdeveloped skills or attitudes affecting the employee’s work. Constructive feedback is generally
Positive feedback: Recognizes excellent work. It’s one way to show your appreciation, build confidence and reinforce positive behaviors.

Process for providing feedback to employees

Feedback is typically most effective when managers provide clear ideas and suggest next steps for progress. Consider following these steps to help your employees:

1. Identify the feedback

Consider the employee’s performance since your last evaluation period. Note their strengths and identify areas for improvement.

For each piece of feedback, make it specific. Specific feedback helps employees understand exactly what they did well or what they can improve. Instead of making a general statement, connect your feedback to a clear behavior, outcome or example from their work. For example, instead of saying, “Your reports are challenging to understand,” you can say, “Your reports might be more accessible if you use graphs to communicate numerical data.”

For your constructive feedback, include suggestions for how they can meet expectations. For example, you might provide department quotas and suggest sales training or mentorship for refining their lead qualification process.

2. Prepare notes

List your positive and constructive feedback, including examples and suggestions. Add notes for other topics to discuss, such as how they can reinforce their strengths or opportunities for cross-training. You might use an employee evaluation form to structure your feedback.

3. Schedule a meeting

Give feedback as soon as possible after you notice an issue or positive behavior. If you’re providing feedback on a presentation or work product, you might send an email or discuss with the employee within a day or two. You can also schedule a one-on-one meeting with the employee to share feedback about their performance.

If you use a self-evaluation form, employees may benefit from having several days to prepare. It may also encourage a more constructive conversation.

4. Share your feedback

You might start your meeting by asking the employee to share the results of their self-evaluation. For example, the form may ask how they’ve represented the company’s mission or ways they’ve helped the team. If you agree with their self-reported strengths, you may offer a few examples to support them before including your constructive feedback.

This strategy reminds the employee that you value them and appreciate their contributions, which can make it easier to accept your suggestions. You can leave time at the end for their thoughts or clarifying questions.

5. End the meeting with positivity

Consider concluding the feedback meeting with positive feedback. Recognizing their accomplishments may improve their job satisfaction. You can also thank them for participating and encourage them to contact you for future guidance.

Employee feedback tips

Here are a few additional tips for giving feedback to an employee:

Be consistent. Make employee feedback a regular part of your communication with your team. When workers expect feedback, it becomes a normal part of the work week.
Offer balanced feedback. Offer both constructive and positive feedback to show employees you value their contributions and support their growth. Make sure they know you’re giving feedback, not criticism.
Make it conversational. Try keeping it conversational, whether you’re giving formal or informal feedback. Encourage the employee to respond and request resources or support as needed.

Positive employee feedback examples

Here are some examples of positive feedback for an employee’s performance:

Overtime: “We really appreciate how you put in extra hours to help the company during the final stages of the project. Thanks to your efforts, we met the deadline without any issues.”
Work performance: “You did a fantastic job on the project proposal. Your attention to detail and careful fact-checking impressed the client.”
Mentorship: “Thank you for taking the time to train our new team member. She’s had a faster time to productivity than the average new hire thanks to your patience, leadership skills and positive attitude.”

Constructive employee feedback examples

Constructive feedback shares useful suggestions in a positive way. Here are some constructive examples to consider when providing feedback to employees:

Work performance: “I’ve always appreciated your hard work and commitment to the company. However, I’ve noticed your sales have declined in the past few weeks, and you’ve been absent from work twice in the past month. I just wanted to connect with you and offer my support to help you meet your targets.”
Employee/coworker feedback: “A few of your coworkers expressed concern regarding your recent interactions. I’d like to get your perspective and offer my support in finding a resolution.”

Recent Employee retention articles

See all Employee retention articles

FAQs about providing feedback to employees

Employees generally appreciate feedback on a one-on-one basis, particularly if it’s constructive feedback. This helps respect their privacy and may encourage open communication between the manager and employee. However, if you’re giving feedback on a work product created collectively, team feedback may be useful. In this case, try to give constructive criticism that applies to the group.

For example, you might praise the team’s innovative solutions and suggest they share information more openly. This feedback can help prevent work silos and resulting redundancies on future projects.

Employee self-feedback, also known as an employee self-evaluation, enables employees to document their strengths and weaknesses at work. They can also provide examples of how they’ve demonstrated their abilities or completed tasks beyond their scope or their role’s general responsibilities.

You can use a standard form to help them assess different skills and performance metrics. Employees might conduct a self-evaluation once a year, typically before a performance review.

You might include these questions on your self-evaluation:

What process did you improve last year?
Is there a specific project outcome you’re proud of?
How do you demonstrate leadership skills with colleagues?
What resources would help you increase productivity?
What parts of your job deliver the most job satisfaction?
How would you like to grow in this role or eventually transition to a new position?
Are there any goals you didn’t meet?
What goals do you have for the next quarter, and how do you plan to achieve them?
What’s a company value you resonate with and demonstrate in your work?

Two chefs, one wearing a red headband, review a laptop and take notes at a wooden table in a kitchen setting.

Ready to get started?

Post a Job

Read our editorial guidelines

Giving Feedback to Employees: A Manager’s Guide

Your next read

What is employee feedback?