Special offer 

Jumpstart your hiring with a $75 credit to sponsor your first job.*

Sponsored Jobs posted directly on Indeed with Urgently Hiring make a hire 5 days faster than non-sponsored jobs**
  • Visibility for hard-to-fill roles through branding and urgently hiring
  • Instantly source candidates through matching to expedite your hiring
  • Access skilled candidates to cut down on mismatched hires

Teacher Recruitment: Strategies for Sourcing and Hiring Teachers

Our mission

Indeed’s Employer Resource Library helps businesses grow and manage their workforce. With over 15,000 articles in 6 languages, we offer tactical advice, how-tos and best practices to help businesses hire and retain great employees.

Read our editorial guidelines
8 min read

When recruiting teachers, aim to embrace new approaches that resonate with the modern educator. Incorporating new teacher recruitment strategies helps schools position themselves as industry leaders, poised to attract and retain exceptional candidates.

The following guidance helps you expand your employer reach while reinforcing your institution’s reputation as a great place to work. 

Ready to get started?

Post a Job

Ready to get started?

Post a Job

Teacher recruitment strategies 

Explore teacher recruiting methods like job postings and career fairs, alongside dynamic strategies such as social media outreach, virtual events and university partnerships.

Traditional methods for recruiting teachers

Traditional approaches still hold significant value and complement newer tactics:

  • Job postings. Advertising teaching vacancies through traditional channels such as online job sites, teacher job boards, industry-specific publications and bulletin boards remains a staple method for hiring teachers.
  • Career fairs. Participating in or hosting career fairs and education job fairs provides opportunities for face-to-face interaction with prospective teachers and allows schools to showcase their unique attributes.
  • Networking. Build relationships within the education community through professional organizations, alumni networks and referrals.
  • Recruitment agencies. Collaborating with recruitment agencies specializing in education can streamline the hiring process.
  • Word of mouth. Word-of-mouth referrals from current staff, students, parents and community members generate interest and bring attention to job openings.

Social media outreach

Beyond conventional job boards and career fairs, social media platforms offer dynamic avenues to reach prospective educators. Craft and engage with compelling content that resonates with your school’s culture and values to create a magnet for teaching candidates.

Go a step further and use targeted advertising and networking groups to amplify your school’s reach. For example, you might attract the attention of passive candidates who aren’t actively seeking employment but could be enticed by your compelling narrative. Embracing platforms such as TikTok facilitates immersive experiences that resonate with the new upcoming generation of tech-savvy, socially conscious teachers. 

In essence, social media is a tool for recruitment and a gateway to fostering a community of passionate educators aligned with your institution’s mission.

Virtual career fairs and networking events

Virtual career fairs and networking events present your school with opportunities to connect with candidates from across the globe. Participation in these events showcases your institution’s unique strengths and values and attracts educators who align with your mission. Hosting or attending them demonstrates your commitment to innovation and inclusivity, making your school an attractive destination for passionate educators seeking growth.

Embrace the flexibility and convenience of virtual platforms to engage with candidates in real time, fostering meaningful connections and leaving a lasting impression. 

University partnerships

Strategic partnerships with universities offer benefits for schools seeking to diversify teacher recruitment efforts. Creating robust relationships with academic institutions can grant you access to a pool of newly qualified candidates who are passionate about education and have the teaching skills you need. 

Aligning with universities can help you establish a pipeline of future teachers with shared values, ensuring a steady influx of dedicated educators who are ready to make a meaningful impact in the classroom. These partnerships can also facilitate opportunities for ongoing professional development and collaboration between faculty members, enriching the educational experience for everyone involved.

Teaching candidate assessment and selection


Traditional methods for candidate assessment and selection in teaching revolve around evaluating degrees, certifications and teaching experience. This involves reviewing resumes, conducting interviews and checking references to gauge candidates’ suitability for the role. 

As the education landscape evolves,  consider incorporating more comprehensive evaluation methods that consider a broader range of factors beyond traditional credentials. Let’s look at some of them. 

Role-playing and collaborative exercises 

Role-playing and collaborative exercises provide a glimpse into how candidates interact with students, collaborate with colleagues and adapt to real-world classroom scenarios. Through role-playing simulations, you can learn about candidates’ instructional skills, classroom management techniques and problem-solving abilities in a controlled environment. Collaborative exercises, on the other hand, allow candidates to showcase teamwork, communication and leadership skills while working with peers. 

Situational judgment tests

Situational judgment tests (SJTs) give candidates a hypothetical situation and options to choose from. This assesses their decision-making skills and ability to navigate challenging situations, providing valuable insights into their approach and attitude.

Here’s an example:

You’re conducting parent-teacher conferences. During one meeting, a parent expresses concerns about their child’s declining grades and lack of engagement in class. They blame you for not providing their child enough support and attention. How would you respond to this situation?

A) Apologize and promise to pay more attention to the student in class
B) Explain your teaching methods and how you strive to support all students equally
C) Listen attentively to the parent’s concerns and ask for specific examples to better understand the situation
D) Defend your teaching approach and emphasize the student’s responsibility for their own learning

In this instance, the appropriate response would likely be C. This demonstrates empathy, a willingness to address the parent’s concerns and a commitment to resolving the issue collaboratively.

Structured behavioral interviews

In a structured behavioral interview, you ask each candidate the same set of predetermined questions. These questions are designed to elicit specific examples of candidates’ behavior in relevant situations. Interviewers ask candidates to describe situations they’ve encountered, the actions they took in response and the outcomes of their actions.

This approach allows for a systematic assessment of candidates’ abilities to problem solve, communicate effectively and demonstrate resilience in challenging situations. To conduct effective structured behavioral interviews, schools should:

  • Develop a set of standardized questions based on the competencies and attributes desired in teachers
  • Train interviewers to ask questions consistently and probe for specific details in responses
  • Use a scoring rubric to evaluate responses objectively and compare their performance against predetermined criteria
  • Incorporate structured behavioral interviews as part of a wider selection process alongside other assessment methods, such as situational judgment tests, teaching demonstrations and reference checks

Teaching portfolios

When evaluating teacher portfolios, look beyond surface-level content. A well-constructed portfolio serves as a window into the educator’s philosophy, methodology and commitment to student success. Here’s a breakdown of what to pay attention to when assessing teacher portfolios:

  • Teaching philosophy. Look for a clear articulation of the candidate’s educational values and beliefs.
  • Instructional materials. Assess the effectiveness of provided materials, such as lesson plans and student work samples, in driving student learning.
  • Innovative teaching methods. Seek evidence of creative teaching approaches, technology integration and ongoing professional development efforts.
  • Organization and presentation. Evaluate the portfolio’s layout and professionalism, indicating the candidate’s organizational skills and attention to detail.

Holistic evaluation criteria

When comparing teacher candidates, consider qualities such as cultural competence, empathy, resilience and the ability to build meaningful relationships. A holistic approach means you evaluate candidates based on their overall fit with the school’s values, mission and objectives. Using a scoring rubric or evaluation matrix ensures fairness, consistency and alignment with your school’s hiring priorities.

The importance of strong employer branding when hiring teachers

When hiring teachers, cultivating a compelling education employer brand attracts aligned candidates and enhances their overall experience. This can help you foster a vibrant and cohesive school community.

Attract strong candidates 

A strong employer brand communicates your school’s values, culture and commitment to educational excellence, making it more appealing to candidates. A positive, supportive workplace with avenues for professional advancement can attract the teacher candidates you’re looking for.

Differentiate

Your employer brand showcases the unique aspects of your institution—its educational philosophy, teaching methodologies and student-centered approach—setting it apart from others. By highlighting the qualities that make your school unique, your employer brand helps candidates understand why they should choose your school over others.

Improve candidate experience

A positive employer brand creates a favorable impression throughout the recruitment journey, from initial contact to onboarding, making candidates feel welcomed and appreciated. Through clear messaging, it also makes it easier for them to become committed members of the school community once they’re hired.

Enhance retention

When teachers are aligned with the school’s brand values, culture and mission, they’re more likely to stay long-term and feel valued. Having a workforce that agrees on key issues cultivates a sense of belonging and camaraderie among colleagues, further solidifying their commitment to the school. Additionally, teachers who feel seen and supported are less likely to seek opportunities elsewhere, leading to greater continuity in educational programs and staff cohesion. 

Get more referrals

Effectively communicating your school’s values and culture through clear brand messaging plays a crucial role in driving employee referrals. That’s because articulating the school’s strengths, unique selling points and commitment to excellence will resonate with current employees who feel proud to be associated with the institution.

Confidence in your school’s brand can motivate teachers to advocate for it among their peers, leading to increased referrals. Strong branding can also help employees accurately convey the school’s value proposition to their peers, making referrals more compelling and persuasive.

Combine traditional and modern teacher recruitment methods for success 

Weaving together traditional and innovative teacher hiring techniques empowers your school to maintain a competitive edge in today’s educational landscape. Incorporating assessment tools such as role-playing exercises, situational judgment tests and structured behavioral interviews ensures a thorough evaluation of candidates’ abilities and suitability for roles. 

Recent Hiring in education articles

See all Hiring in education articles
Streamline Your Hiring
Best practices and downloadable templates for every stage of the hiring process
Get the Guide

Two chefs, one wearing a red headband, review a laptop and take notes at a wooden table in a kitchen setting.

Ready to get started?

Post a Job

Indeed’s Employer Resource Library helps businesses grow and manage their workforce. With over 15,000 articles in 6 languages, we offer tactical advice, how-tos and best practices to help businesses hire and retain great employees.