What is pay compression?
Pay compression happens when pay differences between employees don’t match their experience, skills or responsibilities. It shows up in a few common ways:
- New hires and tenured employees: A new hire can earn as much as or more than an employee with more experience in the same role.
- Recently promoted employees and peers: A newly promoted employee can earn more than peers in similar roles.
- Supervisors and subordinates: Nonexempt employees, who qualify for overtime pay, can earn more than their exempt supervisors, who work the same hours without overtime pay.
Reviewing pay regularly can help you identify unexplained differences and apply compensation criteria consistently. Differences based on protected characteristics may also create legal risk under federal, state or local law.
Signs your business has pay compression
Pay compression often appears in small, everyday details. Watch for:
- New hires who negotiate starting pay close to that of a current employee: For example, a new customer service hire starts at $18 an hour while a three-year employee in the same role earns $19, a difference too small to reflect the added experience.
- Long-tenured employees whose raises don’t match starting salaries for the same role: Consider a five-year HR employee whose pay, despite consistent raises, is only slightly higher than a new hire’s starting wage.
- Exit interviews can also reveal pay compression: If departing employees mention pay as a reason for leaving, compare their pay to a newer coworker’s pay in the same role to identify any discernible patterns.
How does pay compression happen?
Pay compression can develop from wage laws, market conditions or inconsistent internal pay practices.
Minimum wage increases
When states or the federal government raise the minimum wage, it can affect your entire pay scale, moving wages for different experience levels closer together.
Overtime threshold increases
Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), salary level is only one part of determining whether certain employees are exempt from overtime. Salary basis and job duties also matter, and state rules may differ. Review classifications when pay thresholds or responsibilities change.
Increases in starting salaries to match market rates
A competitive labor market can increase starting pay for in-demand roles when market rates rise faster than pay for current employees. You may notice this in fields with persistent hiring demand, including technology and healthcare.
Inconsistent pay practices
Unclear job levels can create pay gaps when roles with different responsibilities share the same range. Defined levels tied to specific responsibilities can help reduce this problem.
Inconsistent pay decisions can also create unexplained differences, including differences associated with protected characteristics. Pay transparency requirements in some jurisdictions may make pay ranges more visible to candidates and employees.
How does pay compression affect your business?
Addressing compression may support retention and morale by showing experienced employees how their pay relates to job-related factors. It may also reduce the cost of replacing employees who leave.
Consistent pay practices can also support your employer reputation. Documented criteria make it easier to explain how starting pay, raises and promotions are determined.
How can small businesses prevent or correct pay compression?
Correcting pay compression takes planning. If the budget cannot address every gap at once, prioritize the widest or least supportable differences and document a timeline for review.
Explain the job-related basis for adjustments, such as market data, changed responsibilities or updated ranges. Use the same decision process for comparable roles.
Here are some ways to counter pay compression.
Establish and review compensation control points
Set clear pay ranges for each role, with a minimum, midpoint and maximum. These ranges guide starting pay, raises and promotions, and help you apply pay decisions consistently across your company.
Decide how your ranges compare with relevant market data and your compensation strategy. Review recruiting and retention results to discover whether the approach supports business needs.
Review pay ranges at least annually and when market conditions, legal requirements or role responsibilities change. More frequent checks may be useful for fast-changing or high-demand roles.
Clarify job descriptions
Review and update the responsibilities and qualifications for each role as the work changes. Clear job descriptions can help support consistent pay and hiring decisions.
Other options for reducing or eliminating pay compression include:
- Offering sign-on bonuses for new hires
- Adjusting base salaries where appropriate
- Making pay adjustments between scheduled reviews
- Providing additional paid time off
With a limited budget, a phased salary adjustment or a combination of pay and nonmonetary options may be appropriate. Evaluate whether each option addresses the underlying gap.
Pay compression is easier to manage when pay ranges, job levels and review schedules are documented. Regular comparisons can help you identify small or reversed gaps and choose corrections that fit your compensation strategy.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Wage, overtime, pay transparency and employee-rights requirements vary, so consult qualified counsel about your circumstances.